M.D. council rejects burning Sandy Lake fireguard timber

The Municipal District of Opportunity No. 17 council is refusing to pile and burn 17 hectares of trees to build the Sandy Lake community fireguard, directing staff instead to see if logging companies will haul the wood away for free.

During its Oct. 26 meeting in Wabasca, council voted unanimously against a push from the Forest Resource Improvement Association of Alberta (FRIAA) to burn the merchantable timber on site rather than harvesting and selling the logs.

FRIAA turned down the M.D.’s Phase 2 construction grant application for the Sandy Lake fireguard on Oct. 15 because the estimated cost of harvesting and hauling the trees was higher than the expected revenue from selling the wood.

Cost estimates prepared by Mistik Environmental peg the M.D.’s preferred log-and-haul plan at $1,038,950, or $936,850 after subtracting $102,100 in expected log sales. By comparison, FRIAA’s preferred pile-and-burn option—where crews knock down the trees and burn them in piles on site—is estimated at $818,800, saving $118,050.

Director of Corporate and Regulatory Services Rolanna Auger told council that administration sent a letter to FRIAA on Oct. 16 defending the log-and-haul plan, but asked if council would support piling and burning the trees if that is the only way FRIAA will fund the project.

Councillors quickly rejected the idea, raising concerns about wasting good timber, leaving dead wood on the fireguard during wildfire season, and filling the community with winter smoke.

“It seems insane that we wouldn’t salvage the logs,” Councillor Robin Guild said. “What a waste of resources.”

Rolanna Auger explained that freshly cut green wood cannot be burned right away in the snow. Instead, the wood piles would have to sit on the fireguard all spring and summer to dry out before being burned the following winter.

“We’re going to have dead vegetation on that fireguard next hazard season,” she said.

Winter smoke was an equally big concern, as weather inversions can trap thick smoke over the hamlet. Councillor Darlene Jackson pointed out that the M.D. previously banned burning brush in Wabasca after hundreds of burn piles on the Wabasca fireguard smoked out residents, and argued the rule should apply across the municipality.

“It should be all communities,” Jackson said. “Especially in the winter, it impacts the air quality really badly.”

Chief Administrative Officer Chad Tullis explained that under the consultant’s estimate, paying a contractor to harvest and haul the logs costs roughly $200,000 more than simply pushing the trees into piles on site.

Still, councillors urged staff to find out if a forestry company would harvest and haul the logs at its own expense in exchange for getting the timber for free.

“I just can’t wrap my head around how it could be more expensive to give the trees away,” Guild said. “The idea of wasting all that wood makes me sick.”

Jackson suggested reaching out directly to major forestry companies working in the region, such as Alberta-Pacific Forest Industries (Al-Pac).

“We could say, ‘Hey Al-Pac, here’s 17 hectares of land—are you interested in just taking the timber at your cost, no cost to us?’” Jackson said.

Rolanna Auger said administration can ask Al-Pac, Vanderwell Contractors, or Zavisha Sawmills if they are willing to take the wood. Council unanimously passed a motion by Councillor Kevin Bigstone to reject the pile-and-burn recommendation and direct administration to look into free logging options.

Armaan Khanna

Local Journalism Initiative Reporter

Share this post

One thought on “M.D. council rejects burning Sandy Lake fireguard timber”

  1. MD needs to start consulting with BIgstone Cree Nation on any projects that are in the Bigstone Traditional Territory; they also have the duty to consult to build data centers and golf courses. Historic trails were destroyed during the construction of the Eagle Point golf course and contaminating the North Wabasca Lake from using herbicides and pesticides on the course.

    Reply

Post Comment